Plenty of Catholic owners feel a small tug every Sunday. The parking lot across the street is full, the competition is open, and the books say Sunday could be one of the best days of the week. Meanwhile the Third Commandment hasn’t changed.

The short answer is that the Church does not require every Catholic-owned business to lock its doors on Sunday. It does ask three things clearly: that Catholics themselves keep Sunday holy, that they not make unnecessary demands that keep others from doing the same, and that employers make sure their employees have time for worship and rest. How a particular business meets those duties is a matter of conscience and prudence, and the answer for a pharmacy will look different from the answer for a print shop.

What the Church actually requires on Sunday

The law is in the Code of Canon Law. Canon 1247 says that on Sundays and other holy days of obligation, the faithful must take part in Mass and “are to abstain from those works and affairs which hinder the worship to be rendered to God, the joy proper to the Lord’s day, or the suitable relaxation of mind and body.”

The test doesn’t ban all activity, and it doesn’t list forbidden trades. It asks whether the work gets in the way of worship, of the joy of the day, or of real rest. A shop owner who works a frantic Sunday and misses Mass has a problem. An owner who opens a few afternoon hours with a willing crew and still worships, rests and spends time with family may not.

The Catechism fills in the picture under the heading “a day of grace and rest from work.” It teaches that “family needs or important social service can legitimately excuse from the obligation of Sunday rest” (CCC 2185). But it adds a warning that applies directly to business: the faithful “should see to it that legitimate excuses do not lead to habits prejudicial to religion, family life, and health.”

Owners and employees are in different positions

The Church’s teaching treats the owner and the employee differently, because they have different power over the schedule.

If you own the business

The owner carries two duties at once: his or her own Sunday observance, and the Sunday of everyone who works there. CCC 2187 is direct about the second: “Every Christian should avoid making unnecessary demands on others that would hinder them from observing the Lord’s Day.” It then says public authorities should ensure citizens a time for rest and worship, and “employers have a similar obligation toward their employees.” The Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church repeats the point (no. 286).

This isn’t new. In 1891, Rerum Novarum said “the employer is bound to see that the worker has time for his religious duties” (no. 20). John Paul II noted in Dies Domini, his 1998 apostolic letter on keeping Sunday holy, that when the Church made laws about Sunday rest over the centuries, she “had in mind above all the work of servants and workers” (no. 66). In Laborem Exercens, John Paul II even counted “a regular weekly rest comprising at least Sunday” among the benefits a fair employer provides, a point we cover in our post on a just wage in Catholic social teaching.

If you work for someone else

An employee who is scheduled on Sunday isn’t automatically sinning. The Catechism recognizes that “traditional activities (sport, restaurants, etc.), and social necessities (public services, etc.), require some people to work on Sundays,” and asks that “everyone should still take care to set aside sufficient time for leisure” (CCC 2187). The obligation to attend Mass still stands, but it can be met at a Saturday evening vigil Mass, since canon 1248 counts a Mass “in the evening of the preceding day.” If a real conflict can’t be resolved, canon 1245 allows a pastor, for a just cause, to grant a dispensation or commute the obligation in individual cases. Talk to your parish priest.

Necessary work and the businesses that serve Sunday

Some work exists precisely to serve people on Sunday, or can’t stop. Hospitals, emergency services, utilities and care homes run every day. Restaurants feed families after Mass. CCC 2185 calls this “important social service,” and Catholic teaching has never treated a nurse on a Sunday shift as a lesser Christian.

Dies Domini also points out that Sunday rest “becomes ‘prophetic'” when it affirms “the primacy and dignity of the person with respect to the demands of social and economic life” (no. 68). That’s the question to bring to your own business. Is Sunday trade serving people, or is it simply squeezing more out of a week that’s already full?

Practical options for a Catholic business

There is no single correct policy. Catholic owners tend to land somewhere on this range, from most to least restrictive.

ApproachWhat it looks likeWhat to weigh
Closed SundaysDoors closed all day, no Sunday shiftsLost sales; clear witness; simplest for staff
Short Sunday hoursOpen midday or afternoon onlyLets staff attend morning Mass; still serves customers
Rotating volunteersSunday shifts are voluntary or rotated so no one works every SundayRequires planning; protects family time
Mass-friendly schedulingShifts built around local Mass times, including Saturday vigilsLow cost; needs a manager who knows the Mass schedule
Online onlyStorefront closed; online orders queue until MondayKeeps revenue; check that “online” doesn’t mean someone works all day anyway

A few habits help whichever approach you choose:

  • Ask new hires whether they need a particular Mass time, and write it into the schedule.
  • Don’t make Sunday the day you answer emails, schedule supplier calls or hold staff meetings.
  • Use the day for the things Sunday is for. The Catechism mentions time with family and “humble service of the sick, the infirm, and the elderly” (CCC 2186).
  • Revisit the decision once a year. A policy set during a slow season may not fit a busy one.
  • If you close, say so simply on your door and website without lecturing customers who shop on Sunday.

For more on bringing faith into day-to-day decisions, see our article on Catholic business principles in the workplace, and our guide to prayer practices for Catholic business leaders.

A note on the law and your employees

Apart from Church teaching, U.S. civil law already protects employees’ religious practice. The EEOC explains that employers generally must “reasonably accommodate” an employee’s religious beliefs or practices, including schedule changes, unless doing so would cause undue hardship. The Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy clarified that “more than a de minimis cost” is not enough to show undue hardship. That protection applies to employees of every faith, not only Catholics. This is general information, not legal advice, so check with an employment attorney about your situation.

Frequently asked questions

Is it a sin for a Catholic to shop on Sunday?

Not in itself. The test in canon 1247 is whether an activity hinders worship, the joy of the day or rest. The Catechism does ask Christians to avoid making “unnecessary demands on others,” which is a good reason to plan ahead rather than run errands out of habit.

Do these rules apply on holy days of obligation too?

Yes. Canon 1247 covers “Sundays and other holy days of obligation.” In practice many holy days fall on workdays in the U.S., so owners often focus on making sure employees can get to Mass.

What if my business would fail without Sunday sales?

The Church recognizes real necessity. Speak honestly with your pastor, protect your employees’ time for Mass and rest, and avoid letting a temporary exception become a permanent habit, as CCC 2185 warns.

Sources and further reading